Username:          Password:
Remember Me:    JOIN NOW  |   Forgot Your Password?
Scott McClellan's book: The culture of deception
By BardofWilmette - Tuesday, July 22nd, 2008 at 2:09 AM
  |   Report Abuse  |   RSS Feed
Add to Google Reader or Homepage      Add to netvibes   Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Friend's Email(s)*
(one per row)
Optional Comments
Your Name:

Your Email*:

I just finished Scott McClellan's book What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washington's Culture of Deception.  It is surprisingly good, or at least it was surprising to me.  This was not, as some had suggested the week the book was released, a book to whitewash his own record, or to settle scores.  It is the thoughtful reflections of a White House insider, who likes and respects George W. Bush, but who also believes that Mr. Bush unwittingly became captive of the "permanent campaign" mentality that led to some destructive consequences.  This included the selling of the Iraq war to the public.  McClellan suggests that the primary motivation behind Bush's decision to invade Iraq was eliminating a ruthless dictator and establishing a democracy that would serve as an inspiring example to Iraq's Arab and Muslim neighbors.   Since the American public was not likely to endorse launching a war for the purpose of bringing democracy to the Middle East, he emphasized and embellished the WMD and the supposed imminent threat to the U.S. and its allies by Saddam Hussein.  Bush and other administration officials were not lying - in the sense of knowingly making false statements of fact.  Instead, they unconsciously cherry picked (as the saying goes) the intelligence, overplaying tidbits of information (without questioning the reliability of that information) that reinforced what they wanted to believe, while downplaying any information that conflicted with their assumptions.  Unfortunately for Mr. Bush, his main justification proved to be false, after he had staked his credibility on the WMD premise. 

The final chapter of the book sums up the problems of the Bush presidency well.  Here is the opening paragraph of that chapter: 

When George W. Bush arrived at the White House, I believed he offered a real opportunity to move beyond the hyperpartisanship and excessive politicking that have come to characterize Washington.  But it was not to be.  The permanent campaign approach we publicly denounced and distanced ourselves from in the 2000 campaign was vigorously embraced after Election Day.  The massive Bush campaign machine was integrally woven into his White House governance, without adequate controls or corresponding checks and balances.  Ultimately, that machine worked not only to spin the media and defeat our opponents but to spin and defeat ourselves

Anyway, I thought the book was well written, and I appreciate the tone of it.  McClellan is sympathetic to Bush, but he also acknowledges that as the president, Bush is ultimately responsible for all the mistakes made by any members of his administration. 



Read BardofWilmette’s Last Article: Obama Should Reconsider the Union Bill

 


Discussion:


Recent Posts
By WeNeedObama - Tuesday, January 6th, 2009 at 12:31 PM
[Cross-Posted on my New Blog, Library Grape.] The Obama team made what I consider to be a political masterstroke yesterday by announcing their selection of respected former Congressman Leon Panetta to head the CIA. Although somewhat mixed, the reactions from the intelligence community have included a lot of praise for the Panetta pick: Former inte more...
By jwilkes - Monday, January 5th, 2009 at 7:46 PM
I think it’s incredible that Beau Biden, the Delaware Attorney General and son of the state’s senior US Senator, went overseas for a tour of duty in the Iraq with his Delaware National Guard Unit. It’s a selfless act of bravery and patriotism. And from a partisan standpoint, I think it’s fantastic because far too few Democ more...
By jwilkes - Saturday, January 3rd, 2009 at 5:08 PM
With his ship taking on water quickly, it’s captain- embattled Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich- is still firing his canons wildly. And much to the vexation of Senate Democrats, he’s actually landing some nasty shots. Despite having been charged with attempting use his constitutional appointment powers to sell President-elect Barack more...
More Posts by BardofWilmette
By BardofWilmette - Monday, December 22nd, 2008 at 1:55 PM
I have been an enthusiastic supporter of Barack Obama’s presidential prospects since the beginning, and his actions since the election have generally acted to reinforce my optimism regarding his coming presidency.  Having said this, however, there are a few issues where I believe he is on the wrong side.  One of these is the misnam more...
By BardofWilmette - Friday, November 28th, 2008 at 3:29 AM
Today was Thanksgiving – a very enjoyable holiday – so why would I risk ruining that positive feeling with a suggestion in very bad taste?  I guess that is just the kind of person I am.  The other day, we all saw the scene on television where Alaska Governor Sarah Palin “pardoned” one turkey at a turkey farm near more...
By BardofWilmette - Saturday, November 22nd, 2008 at 3:27 AM
One of the great things about being an American is that anybody can express his or her opinion, no matter how idiotic it may seem to be.  With that in mind, I have a suggestion regarding a prospective bailout of the so-called “Big Three” Detroit-based automobile manufacturers.  First, a disclaimer, even though it may be so obv more...

Alert!Close


Confirm!Close


FeedbackClose




Email Address:

Comments


Image Verification:
(Case Sensitive)

JoinClose


Username:
Password:
Retype Password:
Email:
Image Verification:
(case sensitive):


Forgot Pass?Close


Username:
Email:
Image Verification:
(case sensitive):


Add FriendClose


To:
Subject:
Image Verification:
(case sensitive)

Compose Message Close


To:
Subject:
Image Verification:
(case sensitive)

Message: